Sites like these always trigger an upswell of nostalgia for me. Looking at these old screenshots I can remember how hip I felt after installing Netscape Communicator and browsing various sites. Perl was the new frontier.
The Internet still seemed like something you could wrap your head around in its entirety, if you tried.
Yeah you're right. I'd be interested in seeing some designers at these companies build something using only the layout and styling tools supported by most browsers of the day.
The choice of codecs and container formats gave me a giggle. It's easy to criticize Flash, but web video was an out and out pain prior to Flash video players.
Since others are handling the arguments over technical and stylistic aspects, I will comment on another problem with the Facebook dedesign:
Pokemon was not yet popular in 1997. The anime scene was all about Ranma, Slayers, Evangelion, Techni Muyo, and whatever movie had aired on the Sci-Fi channel the past Saturday. Sailor Moon was running on TV and was very popular but we tried to forget about that. Of course, the user could be from Japan where Pokemon had been running for half a year, or they could have gotten a sub off Usenet, but Pokemon did not get popular in the English-speaking world until the dub was aired later in the decade.
It's not like the 'fake' ones are particularly funny or anything.