Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

"Go beat/kill this guy" is violence, yet it's just words. Putin haven't killed people with his bare hands(at least for a few years...)But who wouldn't call him violent?

If your sanctions cause people to die, of hunger, sickness or anything else, it's violence.

I'm not against sanctions depending on the circumstances, but you're just wrong



1. "Go beat/kill this guy" is specific targeted incitement.

2. Sanctions are not the same as a blockade. What you're describing is a blockade. To be more specific, suspending trade is not the same an active blockade. I haven't seen any indication to see the current sanctions could even function as a blockade.


Just a note on 1. It’s not incitement when it’s orders. Putin is in a position to give the orders.


> cause people to die, of hunger, sickness or anything else, it's violence

Which would imply famine, poverty, the flu are forms of violence.

This distortion of the English language is so tortured it's just nonsensical at this point.


When one nation causes another to suffer famine, poverty, and a devastating epidemic, that should pretty much qualify as a form of war.


Sanctions are saying “we will not trade with you”. Refusing to trade is violence?

Is it violence if you walk past a homeless guy who is hungry and you don’t give him food?


if you imprison every person who gives or sell food to him then it's violence


If people don't follow Putin's orders, they get imprisoned or executed. His orders are not "just words".


The same as the guy in the article was imprisoned by the United States?

EDIT: Putin puts people in jail for not following marching orders. The U.S. puts people in jail for not following sanctions. It doesn't seem logical to draw a distinction on what is or is not warlike (bullets vs sanctions) based on who jails people, since they both jail people who disobey orders. I assume other factors would be more relevant?


Well only because people follow his orders to imprison those who aren’t following his orders.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: