Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not every TCP server speaks CSRF.

This isn't about 'garbage software'; it's about the expectation that a local LAN is not exposed to the Internet and therefore does not need the same security controls that an Internet-facing network does.

Browsers making requests on the LAN breaks this expectation.

Before someone says "but I don't expect that", well, why do you even have a firewall? With the notable exception of Google/BeyondCorp, practically every LAN in the world expects to trust its members. Having untrusted code in browsers able to send requests on the LAN violates that expectation.



a) You can't establish a plain TCP connection with arbitrary content using a browser.

b) Excepting LAN to be always secure, or okay to keep unsecured is a terrible assumption that has been proven wrong numerous times, it is time to trash that assumption once and for all.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: