Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The interested reader is referred to "Mathematics and Music" by David Wright, published by the American Mathematical Society. The realization that the circle of fifths is really there because 5 and 7 (aka -5) are co-prime to 12 was worth the entire thing! Together with 1 and 11 (aka -1) they generate the group Z_{n} for n = 12...


That explains why the circle of fifths is a circle that goes through all keys, but the really interesting thing about the circle of fifths is that a fifth sounds relatively close to the key next to it, and it doesn't really explain that, I guess.


Any key a fifth away only changes one note - if you go from C Major (CDEFGABC) to G Major (GABCDEF#G) then only the F# has changed, and as a result there are chords which are common between the two keys - any chord without an F in it in C will be common to G as well. Works the other way if you go 'down' a fifth (to F), but has a flat instead. (Bb)


More specifically, going up a fifth augments the fourth by a semitone to become the seventh and going down a fifth diminishes the seventh by a semitone to become the fourth. In your example, F the fourth became F# the seventh and B the seventh became Bb the fourth. A fifth away _IS_ a semitone away.

Defining the following eight functions:

  SEMITONE =  +1 mod 12;  ANTI_SEMITONE = SEVENTH;
  FOURTH   =  +5 mod 12;  ANTI_FOURTH   = FIFTH;
  FIFTH    =  +7 mod 12;  ANTI_FIFTH    = FOURTH;
  SEVENTH  = +11 mod 12;  ANTI_SEVENTH  = SEMITONE;
We ask ourselves why the following holds:

   FOURTH(X) = ANTI_SEMITONE(SEVENTH(FIFTH(X)))
  SEVENTH(X) = SEMITONE(FOURTH(ANTI_FIFTH(X)))
Substituting, the answer is clear:

  X +  5 = X + 7 + 11 - 1
  X + 11 = X - 7 +  5 + 1
Keys one fifth apart differ by one note because:

  1 = 11 + 7 - 5 mod 12
Algebraically it seems to work out...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: